Skip to Content Skip to Main Navigation

Ninth Circuit Forbids School Board Invocations and Censors Private Citizens

in Blog, Cases, Media, Ninth Circuit, Press Releases 10 Comments


Tyler & Bursch, LLP
Contact: Desare Ferraro at 951-600-2733

Ninth Circuit Forbids School Board Invocations and Censors Private Citizens

Chino, CA —Today, the Ninth Circuit Federal Court of Appeals ruled that the Chino Valley Unified School District board policy that allows invocations before the start of school board meetings is a violation of the Establishment Clause. The Fifth Circuit Federal Court of Appeals came to a different conclusion in 2017 in American Humanist Association v. McCarty.

The Ninth Circuit further affirms the District Court’s injunction that enjoins the CVUSD school board members “from conducting, permitting or otherwise endorsing school sponsored prayer in Board meetings.”

“This requires the Board to censor or otherwise remove individuals who attempt to say a prayer, or anything that might resemble a prayer, during the public comment period,” said Robert Tyler of Tyler & Burch, LLP and legal counsel for CVUSD. “Such an overbroad injunction is a clear violation of the right of private citizens to address their local representatives in public meetings and is dangerous to the First Amendment.” Footnote 20 of the Ninth Circuit’s opinion makes this point more clear.

In 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld ceremonial prayer at city council meetings in Town of Greece v Galloway. In that decision, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy noted the historical significance of such invocations. “Ceremonial prayer is but a recognition that, since this Nation was founded and until the present day, many Americans deem that their own existence must be understood by precepts far beyond the authority of government…,” Kennedy wrote.

The CVUSD school board will be meeting in the coming weeks to determine its next course of action.

A copy of the Ninth Circuit’s Opinion can be found here.

The Riverside County law firm of Tyler & Bursch, LLP, represents CVUSD, with the support of Advocates for Faith & Freedom, a nonprofit legal organization.

Email to receive press releases.
Also, join us on Facebook and Twitter to stay up-to-date on our progress in this case and others.
To learn more about Advocates for Faith & Freedom, visit or Tyler & Bursch, LLP, visit

Advocates for Faith & Freedom is a nonprofit public interest law firm dedicated to protecting religious liberty in the courts. The firm, in association with Tyler & Bursch LLP, has represented clients across the country on matters governing land use and religious liberty in the public square.

10 Responses to "Ninth Circuit Forbids School Board Invocations and Censors Private Citizens"

help with assignment says:

You are always bound to get a bad spirit if you invite them to you. Personally, I would ask to be shielded with the white light of the holy ghost. Spirit boards can give the wrong information, remember every spirit doesn’t speak your language.

Essay Writing Services says:

There should be a protection of religious belief of different people. Indeed, a historical amendment plays an important role in today’s era. Tyler & Bursch LLP has been doing a great job so far. Keep this effort alive!

Top Cheap Essay Writing Service Review says:

All these circumstances are really helping them a lot whenever you want to search anything related to you and where you have interest then it will become easier for you to understand, Those who related to this are really establishing something new which will be helpful for them in future.

Best Essay Writing Services UK says:

This post highlighted a great point to be noted in this era, everyone has their own religion and belief that must be protected and have to be followed by their own way, every individual should consider not to harm others in a mean of their following concepts.

Cheap Assignment Writing Service UK says:

The scam services are likely to deceive you with the cheap assignment writing service tag. Nevertheless, they cost you money with a below-par assignment product. This is not the way British Assignment Writing operates, we value our customers, and their satisfaction with our services is our mission. Hence, if you are looking for an impeccably written assignment, contact us right away!

Essay Writing Help UK says:

In case you’re totally ignorant regarding how to begin an individual explanation or attempting to compose the correct arrangement of words because of poor composition aptitude, our own announcement composing administration can give the basic individual articulation to school So for what reason would you say you are as yet pausing? Visit, and get important scholastic assistance from the specialists today. Our online examination enables administrations to contrast significantly than others. It isn’t on the grounds that we give online investigation help with a correct way that students need in the United Kingdom

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *